Shift Supervisor
Oconomowoc, WI, US, 50366
MOD Restaurants make pizza to serve people, to contribute to a world that works for and includes everyone. We believe companies can and should be a force for good in the lives of the people they employ and the communities they serve.
Because at MOD we don’t just make pizzas. We make pizzas that make the world a better place – a world where doing the right thing has far-reaching ripples, where people are at the heart of every decision and were pizza powers possibility.
Compensation: $17.08 per hour. This is $13.75 wage pluse $3.33 per hour in tips, this location has averaged that amount since the start of this year!
Benefits:
- Paid Sick Time
- Paid Vacation of 5 days per year, accruing at 1.54 hours per pay period
- FREE pizza, salad, and beverages
- Pet insurance
- Discounted gym membership
- Free counseling sessions
- Medical, dental and vision insurance eligibility based on hours worked
- 401(k) retirement
Summary
As a part of our Restaurants Leadership team, Shift Supervisors direct the Squad Crew to deliver amazing pizzas and salads to our guests with radical style and personalization. You set the example of what it means to serve, what it means to create a place and platform were everyone can experience pizza that is personal.
You will lead the making of pizzas for the veggie pilers, the pepperoni perfectionists, and the plant-based pioneers. Pizzas built for the carb cutters and the culinary experimentalist. Together we’re creating an experience were pizza is personal, and everyone belongs.
Over 70% of MOD Leaders are promoted internally. When we say everyone belongs it means support our employees reaching for what’s possible. United by a love of great food and good mentorship, our Squad helps each other get to where they are going.
Because at MOD; ALL PIZZAS ARE WELCOME!
Key Responsibilities
- Be an example of MOD values and behaviors and exemplify a service mindset through effective leadership
- Help create a MOD vibe that our customers expect
- Coach Shift Supervisors to keep the energy high and create a positive vibe on the shift
- Demonstrate, train and coach Squad in all methods for accomplishing store tasks
- Demonstrate knowledge of all Operational Standards and resources
- Partner with General Manager to engage the board community of our restaurant
Required Qualifications
- Minimum of 1 year of customer service or restaurant leadership
- Experience successfully leading, coaching, training, and motivating front line employees
- Ability to think strategically and act tactically
- Ability to stay calm and focused in busy restaurant operations
- Must be at least 18 years old
At our table,everyone has a place. Explore your inner pizza enthusiast and feel right at home.Apply todayto work in a restaurant that is also a social movement.
This job posting is not intended to be exhaustive. Other related duties may be assigned to meet the ongoing needs of the organization. At MOD, we believe in creating a world that works for and includes everyone. To request a reasonable accommodation to complete an application, job interview, and/or to otherwise participate in the hiring process, please contact applicantADA@modpizza.com. MOD is a fair chance employer. Los Angeles County qualified applicants with arrest or conviction records will be considered for employment in accordance with the Los Angeles County Fair Chance Ordinance for Employers and the California Fair Chance Act .
Job Segment:Chef, Culinary, Operations, Hospitality
Freqently Asked Questions
In Oconomowoc, WI, a Shift Supervisor often balances close-knit community engagement with operational leadership, unlike larger cities where scale and fast turnover dominate. Supervisors here manage personalized guest experiences and foster team morale in a smaller, community-driven setting, reflecting local values alongside restaurant goals.
Shift Supervisors in fast-casual pizza settings require hands-on leadership, strong multitasking, and the ability to motivate diverse teams under pressure. Being adaptable, maintaining a positive vibe, and coaching crew members to personalize customer interactions are key to thriving in this dynamic environment.
Candidates with proven customer service experience, strategic thinking, and calmness under busy operations excel locally. Leadership in training staff, operational knowledge, and fostering inclusivity are also valued, aligning well with Oconomowoc’s community-oriented workforce expectations.
While no mandatory certifications exist for Shift Supervisors in Wisconsin, knowledge of food safety regulations and compliance with local health codes is critical. Familiarity with state labor laws and accessibility to reasonable accommodation policies enhances leadership effectiveness in local restaurant operations.
Oconomowoc exhibits moderate competition for supervisory roles, with demand rising due to expanding local eateries. Candidates demonstrating leadership and customer engagement skills tend to have an edge. Networking within community-focused companies like MOD SUPER FAST PIZZA also improves hiring prospects.
MOD SUPER FAST PIZZA emphasizes inclusive culture and internal growth, with over 70% of leaders promoted from within. Supervisors here engage deeply with community values, enjoy unique benefits like pet insurance and counseling, and contribute to a socially responsible business model that sets it apart from typical pizza chains.
The company fosters hands-on coaching, encouraging supervisors to lead by example and maintain high energy shifts. They provide ongoing training resources, promote from within, and create a supportive environment to help supervisors build strategic thinking and team management capabilities.
Shift Supervisors earn $17.08 per hour in Oconomowoc, combining a base wage of $13.75 plus an average of $3.33 per hour in tips. This competitive pay aligns with local standards and reflects the role’s leadership responsibilities and customer interaction intensity.
Find The Related Jobs
Sonic Drive In
Shift Manager
Sun Prairie, WI
Planet Group
Supervisor III
Oshkosh, WI
David's Bridal
Retail Supervisor
Brookfield, WI
Circle K
Assistant Manager
Merrill, WI
Circle K
Assistant Manager
Spooner, WI
Circle K
Assistant Manager
Somerset, WI
Jobseekers are also searching for